You’re not obliged to suggest an acquaintance for a job simply because he asks. And when you do, you shouldn’t disguise faults related to that job. However your resistance to recommending this particular person doesn’t appear to be that you just suppose he wouldn’t do a great job; it’s that you just disapprove of his conduct throughout the pandemic.
As an empirical matter, although, there’s purpose to doubt that folks’s character traits are “international” — that the cautious accountant is a cautious driver, that the faithless partner is a disloyal buddy, that the efficient product supervisor will share your smart issues about pointless journey and socializing. So sure, that’s a giant logical leap.
Nonetheless, you’re entitled to say no to suggest him since you suppose that he didn’t show a priority for the frequent good; as an moral matter, you possibly can deny a favor to somebody who, in your view, lacks an necessary advantage. What you possibly can’t do is say you’ll suggest him after which not accomplish that.
I’m in a high-risk group, eligible for a Covid vaccination in each the state I dwell in and a neighboring state. My state is doing a poor job of distributing vaccines, and I’ve didn’t get an appointment. However the neighboring state has a terrific system. A buddy who lives there acquired me an appointment. I do know that they don’t ask to your tackle whenever you arrive to your appointment, which means that they’re not overly involved about residency, and my buddy didn’t misrepresent me when signing me up. Am I proper to really feel a twinge of guilt all the identical? Title Withheld
Totally different states have totally different approaches. Our collective aim, as a nation, is to get as many individuals vaccinated — particularly these at explicit threat — as shortly as we are able to. However as a result of states are allotted vaccines on the premise of their inhabitants, some are taking a agency line, limiting vaccinations to those that dwell or work there; they might require documentation or not less than self-attestation to this impact. Different state officers appear OK with letting guests within the line. As long as you don’t misrepresent your self at any level, you possibly can proceed with a straightforward conscience.
Kwame Anthony Appiah teaches philosophy at N.Y.U. His books embrace “Cosmopolitanism,” “The Honor Code” and “The Lies That Bind: Rethinking Id.” To submit a question: Ship an e mail to [email protected]; or ship mail to The Ethicist, The New York Instances Journal, 620 Eighth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10018. (Embrace a daytime telephone quantity.)